points: 2

Southpark vs Family guy 2

Cartman gets to know Family guy writers. Who exactly are family guy writers? How jokes are made? Southpark got a theory.

featured

by phaet

submitted April 22nd 2006

46 comments
what do you think? let everyone know!
tagged:
votes:
muchoworthyMako
not muchoworthy
comments (46)
I love Family Guy, but watching the DVDs and newer episodes, South park's theory does make some sense. Not OMG SEA CREATURES ARE PICKING OUT IDEAS, but that its completely random ideas for Family Guy jokes.
11 years ago
looks to me like south park are like a bunch of pricks, who are pissed at Family Guy's success.
11 years ago
too bad Trey and Matt have more $$ from the series and their movies then all the people involved with family guy put together. there goes your dumbass theory. think of another now
11 years ago
^agreed! and south park maybe isn't that good as it used to be(there's a bit too much "politics" in the newer eps. if u ask me), but family guy is the lamest shit ever, these joks are for 11 year olds!
11 years ago
Says the man with the online nickname of "aSS-InVader".
11 years ago
who gives a fuck really?
11 years ago
and? who the fuck says that's my "online nickname"?! we're here on muchosucko dickhead!!
11 years ago
So maybe southpark creators are rich. At least they don't deny it. They said in one of the interviews that they wanted to sell themselves and become very very rich looong before southpark started.
11 years ago
Both shows were sweet, but the last season of Family Guy was way too much with the self referencing and flashbacks. Still is better that 98% of the horseshit out there, however.
11 years ago
unfortunately its the 11 year olds that don't really get the pop culture references of family guy.
11 years ago
I think their "pop culture references" are (mostly) lame! Cuz a part of the concept is: If (older) viewers get it, fine! But the same joke also must be funny to a 11 years old who doesnt get it...!

whatever, I just dont like it...^_^ !
11 years ago
I think Simpsons, Family Guy, and South Park are all quickly losing their sharpness. At it's best I think South Park is still the funniest show of the three, but their funny shows are becoming a rarer and rarer thing. Family Guy, I haven't even watched more than a couple episodes since it's come back, and the Simpsons hasn't been funny in 5 years.
11 years ago
I think Family Guy is more suited to 11 year olds than adults. Half the jokes on it are about boobs and poops. I find boobs and poops funny, but only for a very brief period of time.
11 years ago
how can south park rip family guy for usin the same types of jokes on every episode...they killed kenny in nearly every episode for like seven seasons!

only thing about family guy is that outside of america some of the jokes are lost, i admit i dont get all the references but i think thats because im in the UK
11 years ago
The Simpsons has a new writer, that's why it's so shit now. I find South Parks funny episodes sprinkled gingerly throughout the new season and yes Family Guy is getting bad too....but when it IS funny...it's damn funny!
11 years ago
they are no trailerpark boys thats for sure...
easily the funniest show on right now ;/
11 years ago
baltimore80, south park has had it's day and it seems that the creators are blaming Family Guy.
south park appeals to the type of viewer, that doesn't want to concentrate too hard to get the jokes.
fuck knows why aSS-InVader thinks Family Guy's jokes are for 11 year olds, that's total bullshit.
jokes in south park about people shitting themselves and puking over each other is much more childish.
i mean those little dudes that keep going on about farting all the time? come on that's so fucking shit!
11 years ago
Are you watching trailerpark boys on an American network? ...it's classic
11 years ago
Yak has it right, Trailer Park Boys is the best thing going.
11 years ago
"baltimore80, south park has had it's day and it seems that the creators are blaming Family Guy.
south park appeals to the type of viewer, that doesn't want to concentrate too hard to get the jokes.
fuck knows why aSS-InVader thinks Family Guy's jokes are for 11 year olds, that's total bullshit.
jokes in south park about people shitting themselves and puking over each other is much more childish.
i mean those little dudes that keep going on about farting all the time? come on that's so fucking shit!"

You obviously don't pick up on their allusions to being pro-life. And, for fuck's sake, IT'S MEANS IT IS.
11 years ago
whatchoo talkin' 'bout Willis?!
11 years ago
seriously? Is there any heat between family guy and south park?

I would think those guys would be cool,Unlike certain moron rappers.
11 years ago
Southpark jokes are mostly satires so don't think anything offensive
11 years ago
i have to download tpb right now cuz none of the channels in ireland have it.. so thats how im getting the new season :(
i just wish they would start releasing more of the seasons on dvd...
unless they just didnt have them at bestbuy before i left ;)
11 years ago
btw can anyone confirm if the family guy comic strip thats floating around bashing southpark is real?
11 years ago
south park fucking sucks.
all the voices sound the same. the creators are a bunch of closet fags
and the jokes are fucking lame.
half the time they talk about shit they have no fucking knowledge of and sound like total fucking morons.
11 years ago
"too bad Trey and Matt have more $$ from the series and their movies then all the people involved with family guy put together. there goes your dumbass theory. think of another now"

and i'm sure brittney spears makes a hundred times more money than an incredibly talented concert pianist or Carlos Santana.
fuckin moron.
if money is your only representation for worth or talent then you are going to lead a miserable life.
11 years ago
Hey Yak, you'll love this... Bubbles grew up just a few minutes from me, went to my highschool and even the same University as me. Of coarse he is a lot older then me, so I didn't know him, but ran into him once in Halifax at a bar, had a drink with him and talked to him for a few.
11 years ago
that cool ;) bubbles rocks
11 years ago
you're truly blessed if you like both
11 years ago
I agree with loseatlife, south park's "points", if you can call them that, are totally lacking in any insight. As for family guy mostly its just random stupidity with some interjections of pop culture. Personally, the fart/barf jokes or making fun of celebrities doesn't really appeal to me...
11 years ago
South Park = Was very funny with all the profanity and rudeness, now kinda sucks, too many jokes about politicts, as someone said before.

Family Guy = Extremely hilarious 'random' humour, which I love, but some people dont find it funny, it depends on the person. But the jokes lack any whitt or cleverness.

The Simpsons = The very early episodes has a high volume of 'gayness', for example, flashbacks on Lisa and Bart as toddlers, and extremely gay fucking crappy scenes, for example when Bart and Lisa sing a song to their parents about a new babysitter. But the newer episodes (I dont know if anyone has noticed this but the cartoon drawings express far more details and sharpness in comparison to the old ones). But anyway the newer episodes hold such funny jokes, clever and whitty humour. And also the Simpsons does have a certain degree of 'random' humour, like "Family Guy".

So South Park just sucks...Family Guy is good to laugh uncontrollably...The Simpsons is by far the best, and therefore the most successful, because of its cleverness and sexyness etc etc etc etc i like to eat poo all day long, i cant be fucked writing any more fhwfewfhewfhwf woowowowowoowoo!!!!
11 years ago
quite seriously not sure how anyone can still stand the simpsons...
whatever floats your boat tho :)
11 years ago
satsu you have a terrible taste... and you got it all wrong and opposite. The old South Park was not as funny with the toliet humour and kenny dying the newer seasons were much more funny and the older simpsons were much more funnier the horseshit newer stuff they show now.
11 years ago
Oh ok, so you prefer Lisa and Bart singing, Maggie episodes, Santas-Little-Helper running away, Marge singing Maggie to sleep to the newest episodes, no jigsaw99, it is YOU that has terrible taste, and the toilet humour was FAR more evident in the OLDER South Parks, not the newer ones...dumbass.
11 years ago
Oh wait, you actually did get it right, didnt read ur comment properly...dont worry...........ur still a dumbass
11 years ago
I'm right and you're all wrong.
11 years ago
"and i'm sure brittney spears makes a hundred times more money than an incredibly talented concert pianist or Carlos Santana."

and i bet you contributed to that factor too. lmao at you bringing up brittney spears , such a queer
11 years ago
South Park is fucking random. The one with Towlie and Oprah's talking minge; fucked up....

Yak, do you have Sky Digital in Ireland? Trailer Park Boys is on one of their channels, like Sky 1 or something.
11 years ago
How'd the simpsons get into this argument? they try too hard now and their wit seems forced. it's not like the old style of the simpsons that fit so well back then. still think south park has some gems now and then but its kind of fading. FG is just different pace, different type of humor. wish i got all the pop culture references but im not as old as the writers. but that aside i like both south park and FG still. but calling SP random wouldnt be SP. thats more FG. that whole minge n asshole bit was a satire on criminal movies. reminded me of pinky n the brain too. someone should post the orson wells clips here or give a link. its on youtube.com if you wanna search em. classic stuff. wouldnt mind seein the critic ones too.
11 years ago
yeah sky digital... but not satellite... ill have to look if i can find it :)
11 years ago
oh yeah.... ntl digital not sky :(
11 years ago
seems that we have it on paramount comedy!
11 years ago
satsu if you like predicable humour than yeah you have great taste.
11 years ago
predictable*
11 years ago
Didn't any of you Einsteins notice the herbivore manatee eating the yellow fish in the beginning?? OBVIOUSLY this is fake!
11 years ago
recover password
most discussed

below are mucho's most discussed submissions of the last 12 hours. join in on the discussion!